Clayface
I can be anyone. I can be everyone. I can be you.
Abilities
- •Body composed entirely of living clay — can reshape himself into any person, animal, or object
- •Can perfectly mimic any human being's appearance, voice, and mannerisms
- •Superhuman strength — can form his limbs into weapons: hammers, blades, shields
- •Virtually indestructible — can reform from any physical damage, including being blown apart
- •Can increase or decrease his mass and size at will
- •Can envelop and suffocate opponents by engulfing them in clay
- •Originally Basil Karlo, a horror film actor who went mad — later gained shapeshifting clay powers
- •Multiple people have carried the Clayface name, but Basil Karlo is the definitive version
- •Has briefly served as a hero — his desire to be human again is his most sympathetic trait
Powers & Abilities
Biography
Basil Karlo was a horror film actor — the star of a classic movie called “Dread Castle.” When the studio remade his film without him, Karlo snapped. He donned a mask of clay, took the name Clayface, and began murdering the cast and crew of the new production. Batman stopped him, but the name Clayface would outlive the man. Over the decades, multiple people have carried the Clayface identity, each more powerful than the last — until Karlo absorbed all their powers and became the Ultimate Clayface.
Created by Bill Finger and Bob Kane in Detective Comics #40 (1940), the original Clayface was a Golden Age villain with no superpowers — just a clay mask and murderous rage. Matt Hagen, the second Clayface (Detective Comics #298, 1961), was the first to gain actual shapeshifting powers after exposure to radioactive protoplasm. Preston Payne (Clayface III) had a corrosive touch that dissolved anything he contacted. Sondra Fuller (Lady Clay) could shapeshift like Hagen. In “The Mud Pack” (1989), Basil Karlo united all the Clayfaces and injected himself with their combined abilities, becoming the definitive version.
James Tynion IV's Detective Comics (2016) wrote the most compelling Clayface story in modern comics. Tynion put Karlo on Batman's Gotham Knights team as a hero trying to be cured. Basil wanted to be human again — to act, to feel, to have a face that was his own. His teammates believed in him. When he finally lost control and became a rampaging monster, Batwoman was forced to solidify his clay body permanently. It was the most tragic Clayface moment ever written.
Ron Perlman voiced Clayface in Batman: The Animated Series, and the character has appeared in the Arkham video games and multiple animated adaptations. In the comics, Clayface endures as one of Batman's most versatile enemies — a monster who can be anyone, who was once an actor desperate for applause, and who underneath all that living clay is still a man who just wants to be seen for who he really is.
First Appearances — The Clayfaces
Detective Comics #40
1940First Clayface — Basil Karlo, a horror movie actor driven mad when his classic film is remade without him, becomes a killer wearing a clay mask. Bill Finger and Bob Kane create Batman's shapeshifting nemesis. The original Clayface had no powers — just madness and a disguise. A Golden Age Batman key.
Find on eBay →
Detective Comics #298
1961First Matt Hagen Clayface — a treasure hunter exposed to radioactive protoplasm gains the power to reshape his body into anything. The first Clayface with actual shapeshifting powers. The version that defines the "living clay" concept. A major Silver Age Batman key.
Find on eBay →
Detective Comics #478
1978First Preston Payne Clayface (Clayface III) — a scientist who gains a corrosive touch that melts anyone he contacts. He wears an exosuit to contain his dissolving body. The most tragic Clayface. Len Wein and Marshall Rogers.
Find on eBay →
Outsiders #21
1987First Lady Clay (Clayface IV) — Sondra Fuller, a shape-changing member of the Outsiders' rogues gallery. She later marries Preston Payne. Mike W. Barr writes.
Find on eBay →
The Mud Pack
Detective Comics #604
1989The Mud Pack begins — Basil Karlo unites all the Clayfaces: himself, Matt Hagen, Preston Payne, and Lady Clay. Alan Grant writes. Norm Breyfogle draws. The most ambitious Clayface storyline.
Find on eBay →
Detective Comics #607
1989Ultimate Clayface — Basil Karlo injects himself with blood samples from the other Clayfaces and gains all their powers combined. He becomes the Ultimate Clayface — the most powerful version. Grant and Breyfogle.
Find on eBay →
Classic Clayface Stories
Detective Comics #40
1940The original — Karlo as a masked killer stalking a film set. Finger writes classic mystery horror. Kane draws. Batman must unmask the murderer before he strikes again.
Find on eBay →
Batman #208
1969Clayface returns — Matt Hagen's shapeshifting menace continues to haunt Batman. His ability to become anyone makes him the ultimate infiltrator.
Find on eBay →
Detective Comics #478-479
1978Clayface III's tragedy — Preston Payne's corrosive touch is a curse. He falls in love with a mannequin because he can't touch a real person. Rogers draws the most heartbreaking Clayface story.
Find on eBay →
Batman #550
1998Clayface vs. Batman — Karlo with the Ultimate Clayface powers is nearly unstoppable. Doug Moench writes. Kelley Jones draws the most visually terrifying Clayface.
Find on eBay →
Hush & Modern Batman
Batman #608
2002Hush begins — Jeph Loeb and Jim Lee's Batman epic. Clayface impersonates Jason Todd, the dead Robin, to torment Batman. The most famous modern Clayface moment. Lee draws. A top-tier modern Batman key.
Find on eBay →
Batman #614
2003Clayface revealed in Hush — his impersonation of Jason Todd is exposed. Loeb writes the twist that makes Clayface central to the greatest modern Batman story.
Find on eBay →
Batman: The Dark Knight vol. 2 #1
2011New 52 Clayface — David Finch writes and draws. Karlo is reimagined for the modern era. His powers are more horrifying than ever.
Find on eBay →
James Tynion IV's Detective Comics — Clayface as Hero
Detective Comics #934
2016Clayface joins Batman's team — James Tynion IV writes Basil Karlo as a member of Batman's Gotham Knights alongside Batwoman, Orphan, Spoiler, and Batwing. Karlo wants to be cured. He wants to be human again. The most sympathetic Clayface ever written.
Find on eBay →
Detective Comics #940
2016Clayface earns trust — Tynion writes Basil proving himself to the team. He uses his shapeshifting to help, not deceive. His desire for redemption is genuine.
Find on eBay →
Detective Comics #961-963
2017Clayface's struggle — Tynion writes Basil losing control of his clay form. The cure is slipping away. His teammates fight to save the man inside the monster.
Find on eBay →
Detective Comics #973-974
2018Clayface's fall — Basil loses control completely. He becomes a rampaging monster. Batwoman is forced to use a weapon that solidifies his clay permanently. Tynion writes the most tragic Clayface moment in modern comics.
Find on eBay →
Batman: The Animated Series Impact
Detective Comics #40
1940The source — the animated series' two-part "Feat of Clay" episode made Clayface one of the most beloved Batman villains. Ron Perlman voiced Matt Hagen. The animated version drew from all the Clayface iterations.
Find on eBay →
Detective Comics #298
1961Matt Hagen — the animated Clayface was primarily based on this version. The shapeshifting actor became the template for every adaptation.
Find on eBay →
Batman Adventures #12
1993BTAS comic — the animated universe comics feature Clayface prominently. The show's influence made Clayface a household name for an entire generation.
Find on eBay →
Clayface in Batman Events
Batman #1
2011New 52 Batman — Scott Snyder and Greg Capullo launch the definitive modern Batman. Clayface appears as one of Gotham's most dangerous threats throughout the run.
Find on eBay →
Batman Eternal #1
2014Batman Eternal — Snyder's weekly series features Clayface as part of Gotham's villain landscape. His shapeshifting makes him invaluable to any criminal conspiracy.
Find on eBay →
Batman vol. 3 #118-121
2022Clayface in modern Batman — Joshua Williamson writes. Karlo continues to evolve between villain and antihero. His identity crisis is permanent.
Find on eBay →
Clayface's Defining Moments
Detective Comics #40
1940The debut — a mad actor in a clay mask. Finger and Kane create the original Clayface. Horror on a film set.
Find on eBay →
Detective Comics #298
1961Living clay — Matt Hagen gains the shapeshifting powers that define all future Clayfaces. The monster is born.
Find on eBay →
Detective Comics #607
1989Ultimate Clayface — Basil Karlo absorbs all Clayface powers. He becomes the definitive version. Grant and Breyfogle.
Find on eBay →
Batman #614
2003Hush — Clayface impersonates Jason Todd to break Batman. Loeb and Lee. The most famous modern Clayface moment.
Find on eBay →
Detective Comics #934
2016Becoming a hero — Tynion writes Karlo joining Batman's team. The monster wants to be a man. The most sympathetic Clayface.
Find on eBay →
Collector Highlights
Detective Comics #40
1940The holy grail — first Clayface. Finger and Kane. A Golden Age Batman key. Extremely scarce in any grade.
Find on eBay →
Detective Comics #298
1961First Matt Hagen Clayface — the shapeshifting version. A major Silver Age Batman key.
Find on eBay →
Detective Comics #478
1978First Clayface III — Preston Payne. Wein and Rogers. A significant Bronze Age key.
Find on eBay →
Detective Comics #604
1989The Mud Pack — all Clayfaces unite. Grant/Breyfogle. A collectible Copper Age key.
Find on eBay →
Batman #608
2002Hush — Loeb/Lee. Clayface impersonates Jason Todd. A top-tier modern Batman key.
Find on eBay →
Detective Comics #934
2016Tynion's Detective — Clayface as hero. The most acclaimed modern Clayface arc.
Find on eBay →